Netgear Orbi vs Eero: Pros & Cons and Verdict

Estimated reading time: 15 minutes

Netgear Orbi and Amazon Eero are the two most popular mesh Wi-Fi systems on the market today. Both systems are known for their ability to meet the ever-increasing demand that devices place on smart home Wi-Fi.

The technology of the mesh router, allows each of its routers to communicate with one another, creating a fluid connection and the ability to hold up seamlessly over large areas.

This means that it can access every corner of a home, regardless of how far you are from the actual router. With this system, your devices connect directly to the “mesh” network instead of having to reach all the way to the router.

With either of these, you’ll be getting a Smart Home System that provides strong, reliable Wi-Fi, and a fast network.

The NETGEAR Orbi is a better system than the Eero. It offers faster speed over a larger area, with more ethernet ports and daisy-chaining for flexible unit placement.

But there’s a lot to consider before shelling out the cash for a top-notch Wi-Fi system. Let’s take an in-depth look at Orbi and Eero and talk about how they stack up against each other.

How We Tested

We put the Orbi and Eero systems through the same testing. We went through the setup and configuration process, putting ourselves in the shoes of the average customer.

After setup, we simply connected our device to the newly available Wi-Fi network and tested the connection speed.

We made 2 different tests one for the the standard versions the Orbi rbk50 vs the Eero Pro and another test for the Wi-Fi 6 versions Orbi rbk752 vs Eero Pro 6 these are the Wi-Fi 6 models.

Orbi rbk50 vs the Eero Pro

These are the most affordable models in both the Orbi and the Eero. The pricing for these are as follows; 

• The Orbi rbk50 is around $280; Check The Latest Price (our pick)
• Eero Pro is around $290; Check the Latest Price.

Orbi rbk50

The Netgear Orbi system was first up. About 10 feet away from the main router, we consistently got speeds of over 500 Mbps, which is pretty incredible.

As we got further and further away from the router–about 35 feet–the speeds did decrease but never dropped below 200 Mbps. Next, we connected the device to the one Orbi satellite unit and measured it at the same distances.

The averages were nearly identical, proving that the Netgear Orbi system delivers on its promises of lightning-fast Wi-Fi regardless of router proximity. 

Eero Pro

Next, we did these exact same tests with the Eero Home Wi-Fi system. About 10 feet from the Eero main router, we measured an average speed of 388 Mbps. Not bad. From 35 feet away, the speeds dropped, as expected, but fell beneath 180 Mbps only on occasion.

We then connected to one of the Eero beacon units (which is an extender to the mesh system), and, same as the Netgear Orbi, there was no significant difference in speeds between the main router and the beacons. 

The Rbk50 Wins

Our tests proved that while both systems are powerful and extremely steady, the Netgear Orbi rbk50 has consistently faster speeds and is the clear winner. However, the Eero is cheaper than the Orbi.

Orbi RBK752 vs Eero Pro 6 

Orbi RBK752 and the Eero 6 are Wi-Fi 6 models and are beasts! The pricing for these are as follows; 

• Orbi RBK 752 – $449
• Eero Pro 6 – $549

Orbi RBK752

Next up was the Orbi RBK752. We started with the same test as the RBK50 at 10 feet from the router we hit peeks at a whopping 803MBps and the average speed was 730 MBps! 

Then when we went 35 feet away we saw a difference but never went under 500MBps. And then at 50 feet, it went down to 300 MBps.

Eero Pro 6

The Eero 6 at ten feet did not do as well as the Orbi RBK752 the average speed was around 490MBps, and at 35 feet average was 285MBps. 

Orbi RBK752 Wins

Our tests proved that while both systems are powerful and extremely steady, the Netgear Orbi has consistently faster speeds. Orbi RBK752 Wins The Wifi-6 speed comparison. The real takeaway, however, is those Wi-Fi 6 systems are the real deal.

Design: Orbi vs Eero

Netgear Orbi

The Netgear Orbi Kit comes with two or more units, one main router, and one or more satellite units, all of which are mostly identical.

The satellite units are long, plastic cylinders colored in plain white, while the main router is white with a splash of blue on top.

The Orbi is lightweight, which, given its height, makes it easy to knock over, so be careful where you place it.

These units look sleek and modern. In place of the old blinking LED lights, Orbi has instead opted to display the status via a single light on the top of the device on the Orbi rbk50, and a striped light on the Wi-Fi 6 model.

If your unit is disconnected from the internet, the device will display a steady purple light, and if it’s rebooting itself, a flashing white light will appear.

This light system does forfeit a small amount of functionality in favor of style. 

Overall the Netgear Orbi system blends in well with most types of furniture, and though the units don’t add much, they definitely don’t subtract to the appearance of your home. 

The most impressive aspect of Orbi’s units is that each one comes equipped with four Gigaport ethernet ports.

Amazon Eero

The standard Eero comes with a very similar setup to the Orbi: one main router as well as one or more “beacons” (Eero allows you to purchase additional beacon units to extend the coverage as needed).

The units featured in the Eero kit are a good deal smaller than those featured in the Orbi kit and lie flat instead of standing upright, making them less intrusive physically and visually.

The LED light used for the Eero unit is quite well done: One small light, plainly in view on the face of each unit, displays a solid white light when connected to the internet, a solid red light when unable to connect, and a blinking green light to indicate system errors.

• 

• 

Eero’s design wins

Both systems are sleek, minimalistic, and attractive. While there’s not a huge advantage, either way, Eero’s design gets the slight edge here.

While this type of system seems to be inherently weaker than the traditional blinking LED displays featured on older routers, Eero has done a good job modernizing the design without sacrificing too much functionality.

Both systems are sleek, minimalistic and attractive. While there’s not a huge advantage either way, Eero’s design gets the slight edge here.

Setup

Eero's Lightning-Fast Setup

When it comes to ease of installation and setup, Eero cannot be beaten. The product truly excels in these areas, consistently receiving rave reviews. Simply plug in the units, download the app on a mobile device, and follow the instructions.

After installation, the Eero app allows you to easily view your network, monitor device usage, and share or limit your internet as you see fit. 

You can allow guests to access Wi-Fi while keeping your passwords off-limits. Perhaps the most useful feature of this app comes in the form of parental control.

Parents can easily set which times certain devices can connect to the internet. The setup is quick, hassle-free, and easily customizable. And after installation, Eero automatically updates and troubleshoots itself. 

• Eero lacks advanced customization

The only downside for Eero’s installation is the same thing that makes it great: the simplicity of the app. While great for most, Eero might lack the advanced customization that more knowledgeable users seek.

Netgear Orbi

Not as exceptional as Eero, Orbi also features a very fast and easy setup process. Simply plug in and connect the base router to the ethernet port in your ISP modem.

You’ll then need to connect your device to the router. Once you’ve done that, you’ll just follow the simple step-by-step guide. This is an easy process that requires no tech-savvy.

There’s no need to assign IP addresses or fuss with renaming networks. The process for adding additional units is also very simple. Just plug them in and power on.

Setup Verdict

Both products are extremely easy to install, set up, and use. Eero gets the edge here, though not due to any wrong-doings on the part of Orbi. Eero’s setup process is extraordinarily simple.

Performance

We already know that “mesh” systems provide great quality Wi-Fi. These are truly the systems of the future, and it’s not hard to see why. They outperform traditional Wi-Fi systems in almost every area, certainly every significant one.

How do these particular mesh systems compare to each other in terms of coverage? 

Amazon Eero

Eero uses tri-band routers as opposed to a dual-band, which allows the system to cover a much larger area in high-quality Wi-Fi, while also allowing a higher number of devices to connect.

When it comes to Wi-Fi speed and reliability, the Wi-Fi this system provides, while not quite as strong as Orbi’s, is still very fast and reliable. The one area in which Eero falls considerably behind is area coverage.

The Eero Pro and Eero Pro 6 cover the same square feet; the only difference is that the Pro 6 uses Wi-Fi 6, and it's faster.

• 1 Eero Router and 2 Beacon Units (only available in Pro version) – This second beacon adds an additional 1000 sq. ft. of coverage, taking the coverage area for this kit up to 3000 sq. ft. total, which is the size of a typical 3-bedroom home.
• 3 Eero Routers – The largest kit offered simply includes 3 Eero routers, leaving the smaller beacon units out altogether. This kit provides steady Wi-Fi across an area of 3500 sq. ft. If you’re home or office is bigger than this, you’ll need to purchase additional routers or beacons as necessary.

Netgear Orbi

Orbi provides some of the fastest Wi-Fi you can imagine. The product is adored for its super-fast speeds and wide coverage range. Even the largest homes usually fall easily within this product's coverage range.

Although Eero has taken giant strides in catching up, Orbi still provides the fastest Wi-Fi on the market. Their tri-mesh system allows you to take your device anywhere in the home without having to disconnect and reconnect to different units.

With Orbi’s Wi-Fi system, you get one continuous web of unbelievably high-quality Wi-Fi from wall to wall and floor to ceiling.

The Orbi systems can cover up to 5,000 square feet, This outstanding coverage area means that fewer people will need to buy additional units, which, when dealing with such expensive systems, is a huge plus.

Orbi has a dedicated backhaul which allows your network to continue functioning during any times you might have an increased number of clients and nodes.

Features

Netgear Orbi Features

• Super-Fast Wi-Fi: You'll get the fastest Wi-Fi on the market. No matter how many devices you connect, the Wi-Fi remains consistent and fast.
• Industry Leading Coverage: With just 2 units, Orbi provides over 5,000 sq ft of coverage.
• Compatibility: Orbi works with all major internet providers including Verizon, Comcast AT&T, and more.
• Convenient App: The Orbi app allows for easy customization of your Wi-Fi. 
• Effortless Setup: No need to assign IP addresses or rename networks.
• Pairs with Amazon Alexa/Google Assistant: Use voice commands to control your Wi-Fi. You can ask Alexa to enable Wi-Fi for your guests or have her tell you the current settings.
• Advanced Setup (if Desired): Orbi gives technologically inclined users the ability to have total control and tinker with every facet of the settings.
• Parental Controls: Great parental control features allow you to easily limit screen time and content on any device.
• Memory: 4GB Flash and 512 MB RAM
• Ethernet Ports: Each unit comes equipped with 4 ethernet ports.
• Special Networks for guests: Configure a separate password for guests without having to share your home password. 
• Daisy Chain Networking: Daisy chain networking allows for each unit to connect with one another, offering you great placement flexibility.

Amazon Eero Features

• 1 Router and up to 3 Beacon Units: The Eero home Wi-Fi system is available in 3 different kits, featuring 1, 2 or 3 beacon units, depending on your needs. The main router, as well as these beacons, are well designed and non-descript. Users love the way they blend into their homes.
• High Speed Wi-Fi: Eero provides powerful Wi-Fi coverage able to handle a large amount of users and devices without slowing down. 
• Convenient App: While Orbi’s app is good, Eero’s app is great, especially when it comes to installation.
• Effortless Setup: Eero’s system is unbelievably easy to set up, making it perfect for the average user.
• Service Compatibility: Like Orbi, Eero works with all major internet providers, including Verizon, At&T, Comcast and more.
• Memory: 1 GB flash storage and 512 MB of RAM.
• Built-in Bluetooth: Allows you to easily sync to your mobile devices.
• Large Coverage Area: Although Eero’s coverage area–only about 3500 sq. ft. without purchasing additional beacon units—is definitely the weakest aspect of the product compared to its main competitors, the system still offers users a massive upgrade from traditional non-mesh systems. 

Alternatives

Although Google’s system lacks some of the advanced features of Eero and Orbi—the backhaul capability being the most notable of these absences—it is a slightly more affordable option.

The only place where Google’s system really excels is physical design. If you’re looking for a good-looking, capable albeit less advanced, mesh Wi-Fi system that’s user-friendly and more affordable–The Google Home Mesh system might be the perfect choice for you.

Why Upgrade to Mesh WiFi?

Mesh Wi-Fi systems are perfect for anybody who wants to cover a large area in excellent Wi-Fi. If your home is large or has an unusual layout, you’re probably used to experiencing Wi-Fi dropouts or dead zones.

Mesh Wi-Fi systems are the answer to this problem. If you want to avoid these dead zones, want to support multiple devices simultaneously, or want to run powerful gaming engines with confidence, either the Netgear Orbi, or the Eero Home Wi-Fi system will work wonders for you. 

Our Pick

Overall, these are two great products. Each system has its own small set of flaws and a large set of strengths. There can be only one winner, however; and in our opinion, the Netgear Orbi’s strengths proved to be more significant.

Upgraded Wi-Fi 6 Pick