Getting a good night’s sleep is so important, and the first step is choosing the right mattress. These days, there are a lot of different mattress brands out there, with many specializing in foam and hybrid mattresses that are able to offer impressive levels of comfort, support, pressure relief, and motion isolation.
Casper and Leesa are two of the leading lights in the mattress industry, with both companies offering a range of mattresses at various prices and sizes, and many mattress shoppers find themselves hesitating between the two brands, unsure which one is the right choice for them.
Casper and Leesa mattresses have many similarities, with both brands providing comfortable, supportive mattresses made with industry-leading materials, along with solid sleep trials, warranties, and competitive prices too, but there are some differences that can help to set them apart, and we’re here to help you make the right choice.
We’ve compared these two brands inside and out, looking at a range of key factors like mattress range, firmness levels, prices, cooling, comfort, sleep trial length, and more, in order to give you a full and frank overview of each side, making it much easier to choose between them.
How We Started
Table of Contets
Since both Leesa and Casper offer a range of different mattresses at varying price ranges, we chose to test several options from both companies at three different price points: High-End (From $1,200), Mid-Range (From $850), and Low-End (From $500).
Mattress comfort can be quite a subjective issue, and many people will respond differently to different types of mattress. If you have back pain, for instance, you might find a firmer mattress to be more comfortable, while those who sleep on their sides or stomachs might prefer a certain type of mattress foam to another.
Because of this subjectivity, we can’t offer definitive conclusions for any of these mattresses in regard to their universal appeal, but we can tell you how they fared in our tests, looking at key factors like their firmness ratings, motion isolation, and cooling, as well as pricing information, warranties, sleep trials, and more.
Evidently, finding the right mattress can really have a big impact on your overall health and lifestyle, with a good mattress helping you drift off to sleep and enjoy a peaceful rest each night, resulting in lower stress levels, a healthier mind and body, and renewed energy levels each morning, ready to face the day ahead.
Our reviews aim to help you find the right mattress to improve your life, and we found that both brands offer some really good mattresses overall, with plenty in common and some interesting areas of divergence, so let’s take a closer look and see where the key differences lie.
Similarities and Differences
When you first look at Casper and Leesa, you’ll notice that these brands seem to have a lot in common. They both offer several mattress models, including foam and hybrid offerings, with each brand offering a budget-friendly option, a mid-range mattress, and a high-end choice.
They both sell pillows, bed frames, and other accessories too, and both brands aim to appeal to a wide range of users, marketing their mattresses to sleepers of all types and body sizes. Whether you’re a side sleeper, a back sleeper, a heavy sleeper, or a light sleeper, you can find options from both Casper and Leesa that can meet your needs.
Both brands stick to Medium and Medium Firm mattresses, ranging from 5-6 on the firmness scale, and they also offer 10-year warranties and 100-night sleep trials too. What’s more, both brands offer mattresses that provide that classic memory foam feel, with reasonable levels of bounce and thin, breathable, polyester covers. So with all these similarities, where can the differences be found?
Well, pricing is one area in which the two companies differ. On average, you’ll pay less for a Leesa mattress. Casper tends to have slightly cheaper prices for smaller sizes, like Twin and Twin XL, but once you get into the larger sizes, like Queen and King, the costs go up quite quickly, much higher than Leesa.
When we take a closer look at how the mattresses perform in real world tests, we can also notice some differences. Leesa mattresses, for example, tend to offer a little more edge support and less off-gassing than Casper mattresses. However, Casper typically has the edge in terms of zonal support and temperature control.
High-End Products
Leesa Legend
When it comes to high-end mattresses, the Leesa Legend is one of the top options out there. If you care about comfort, quality, and a good night’s rest, this is one of the top mattress choices for you. The Leesa Legend is a hybrid mattress with an impressive 6-layer construction.
It features 1″ of comfort foam on top, 1″ of pressure-relieving memory foam beneath, then a 1.5″ micro-pocket spring layer, another inch of transition core support foam, 6″ of pocket springs with edge support, and 1″ of support foam at the base. All of this is covered with a natural, knitted cover made from organic cotton.
The Leesa Legend is breathable, responsive, and terrific when it comes to pressure relieving support. The memory foam layer contours to your body, without excess sinkage, and the pocket spring coils help to keep the spine aligned through the night, perfect for those who suffer from back aches and pains.
The cover of the Leesa Legend is highly breathable too, and the various layers have been designed to wick moisture away and absorb heat from the body, preventing you getting too hot in the night. It’s a good fit for both side and back sleepers, and the only real downside to the Leesa Legend is its price. It’s one of the most expensive mattresses out there.
Leesa Legend Features
- Available in a range of sizes from Twin XL to Cal King
- Firmness ranging from 5-7
- Hybrid construction with various foams and springs
- CertiPUR-US certified
- Impressive edge support
- 100-night sleep trial
- 10-year warranty
- Polyester cover made from recycled water bottles
Overall, there’s a lot to love about the Leesa Legend and it feels absolutely fantastic to sleep on. The comfort levels are through the roof with this model, and it offers solid edge support for a hybrid foam mattress, as well as phenomenal pressure relief.
It’s also nice to see that Leesa made use of various recycled materials, including polyester on the covers and recycled steel in the springs, helping the Legend stand out as an eco-friendly choice.
If you can afford it, this is one of the top mattresses around.
The Leesa Legend mattress is not only our most luxurious mattress, it’s our most sustainable, featuring natural and recycled materials that are good for your sleep and the planet. The Legend features polyester from recycled water bottles—73 in a king mattress cover, to be exact—and mattress springs made of recycled steel.
Casper Wave Hybrid
Over on the Casper side, the top mattress to choose from has to be the Wave Hybrid. This is one of Casper’s best ever mattress creations, blending ergonomic, comfortable foam and cooling gel with solid, supportive springs. The Casper Wave Hybrid offers a 5-layer construction.
On top, you’ll find a thin layer of cooling gel-infused AirScape foam for breathability, followed by an additional layer of AirScape with breathable holes. The third layer is also made of AirScape foam with zonal support for the spine, hips, waist, and shoulders, then there’s the fourth layer, made of Zoned Support Max foam with gel pods to provide additional spinal alignment and support.
Finally, the base is made from a thick layer of springs that provide the support and lift to maintain the mattress’ shape, even under pressure. This combination of layers helps to provide impressive levels of support all through the body, and the zonal support is great for those who struggle with any aches or issues around their hips, lower back, or shoulders.
In terms of cooling and breathability, the Wave Hybrid features perforated AirScape foam with several air channels to help heat escape, as well as the cooling gel on top and a thin, polyester cover made from recycled materials. It’s available in more sizes than the Leesa Legend too, but is more expensive overall.
Casper Wave Hybrid Features
- Available in sizes from Twin to Cal King
- Firmness rating of 6
- Hybrid construction with foams, springs, and gel
- CertiPUR-US certified
- Great pressure relief
- 100 night sleep trial
- 10 year warranty
- Recycled materials cover
The design of the Casper Wave Hybrid makes this one of the best mattresses in the business when it comes to pressure relief and support. Ideal for back and side sleepers in particular, as well as those dealing with back pain, its design, particularly the gel pods, is able to provide incredible levels of comfort.
The extra price you’ll need to pay for this model over the Leesa Legend may be off-putting to some users, and both mattresses excel more or less equally well in terms of comfort, support, firmness, motion isolation, and edge support too, so it’s almost impossible to say that one is better than the other.
Overall, the Wave Hybrid has the edge in terms of breathability and temperature control, while the Legend might just be a little better in terms of pressure relief. But if you can afford either one of these mattresses, you won’t regret your decision, as both of them are some of the best you can buy.
Casper is reimagining sleep from the ground up. All of Casper’s sleep products are developed in-house by our award-winning research and development team. The Wave Foam has our ultimate support meaning less aching and more sleeping.
Mid-Range
Leesa Hybrid
When it comes to mid-range mattresses, Leesa offers up the Leesa Hybrid. Arguably the best all-round mattress in the Leesa line-up, this particular model has a lot to offer in all the key areas. It’s an award-winning hybrid mattress that aims to blend all the benefits of foam and springs into one perfect package.
The Leesa Hybrid features a 5-layer design. On the top, you’ll find 1.5″ of cooling premium foam, followed by 1.5″ of memory foam to contour around the body. This is followed by 1″ of core support foam, then 6″ of quantum core pocket coils, with over 1,000 pocket springs. Lastly, there’s a final inch of core support foam.
The construction of the Leesa Hybrid allows it to offer impressive comfort levels. It offers solid support for the shoulders and hips, with impressive responsiveness and bounce. The memory foam contours nicely around the body, with some sinkage, and this mattress also provides reasonably strong edge support too.
What stands out about the Leesa Hybrid is its lively and responsive nature. It can work well for couples or combo sleepers who like to move around during the night, and the firmness rating of 6.5 helps to offer a good compromise that will appeal to a lot of sleepers. Stomach sleepers may not enjoy this mattress, however.
Leesa Hybrid Features
- Several sizes from Twin to Cal King
- Firmness rating of 6.5
- 100-night sleep trial
- 10-year warranty
- Knitted cover
- Made in the USA
- CertiPUR-US certified
Overall, there’s a lot to like about the Leesa Hybrid, even if it falls short in one or two areas. Stomach sleepers probably won’t find this mattress firm enough to meet their needs, but apart from that, it’s an amazing mattress that performs really well in all the key areas.
Experience advanced comfort and support with the best of foam and springs in the Leesa Hybrid: premium foams provides body contouring, pressure-relief and bounce, while 1,000+ pocket springs give you edge-to-edge support.
Casper Nova Hybrid
If you’re looking for a mid-range offering in the Casper catalog, the Nova Hybrid is the one for you. This model sits nicely between Casper’s Original and Wave Hybrid models in terms of price, and it has a lot to offer in terms of comfort and pressure-relieving support as well. In terms of construction, the Casper Nova Hybrid features four distinct layers.
You’ll find a top layer of breathable AirScape foam, followed by zoned polyurethane foam, some contoured memory foam that hugs the body nicely, and a durable base layer of support foam and springs. All of this is covered up by a super soft, stretchy cover that feels really cozy and soft to the skin.
When it comes to comfort and feel, the Nova Hybrid is a very impressive mattress. The AirScape foam and perforated layers help to keep you cool through the night, while the zonal support of this mattress offers specialized levels of comfort for the hips, lower back, and shoulders. This is a terrific choice, therefore, for those who seek spinal alignment in their mattresses, as well as those who have bodily aches and pains that might keep them up at night.
When it comes to firmness, the Nova Hybrid is actually quite soft, ranking at about 5.5 on the firmness scale. It’s a plush mattress, and most average and heavy sleepers will notice themselves sinking through the top layers onto the zonal coils. This makes it a good choice for back and side sleepers, but less suitable for stomach sleepers.
Casper Nova Hybrid Features
- Size range from Twin to Cal King
- 5.5 firmness rating
- 100-night sleep trial
- 10-year warranty
- CertiPUR-US certified
- Great breathability and temperature control
- Impressive pressure-relieving zonal support
The Nova Hybrid is more expensive than the Leesa Hybrid, so you’ll need to pay extra to enjoy some of its advantages like the zonal support and temperature control. It definitely excels in these areas, but the softness may be off-putting to some.
Overall, each of these mattresses has its pros and cons. The Leesa Hybrid is probably the better choice for couples, due to its impressive motion isolation and responsiveness, while the Nova Hybrid has the advantage of being stronger for those who need more support along their spine.
Resilient springs add a little lift, support and airflow to the mattress of your dreams. A firmer border provides edge support to help you get in and out of bed easily. The knit mattress covers have four way stretch, so you feel the full benefits of the below layers. Still unsure? Rest easy with our 100-night trial and free returns.
Low-End
Leesa Original
The Leesa Original is the most affordable offering from this leading bed-in-a-box company, and it was the Leesa Original that really helped to put Leesa on the map. Since its creation, other models have surpassed it in terms of design and comfort, but the Original still has plenty to offer for budget-conscious buyers.
The Leesa Original is a 10″ mattress with three different foam layers. The top layer is made up of 2″ of cooling foam, while the middle layer features 2″ of memory foam, and the base layer offers 6″ of support foam. All of this is covered by Leesa’s classic four-stripe cover.
In terms of comfort and performance, the Leesa Original is pretty bouncy and responsive, standing out as another terrific option for couples. It’s also quite good when it comes to temperature control, with the cooling foam layer helping to absorb heat and moisture through the night.
Moving around in the Leesa Original is quite easy, thanks to its firmness of 6.5, and it offers quite a strong, supportive feel, a little firmer than many counterparts. Back and stomach sleepers will find a lot to like about the Leesa Original, but side sleepers may struggle to get totally comfortable.
Leesa Original Features
- 6.5 firmness rating
- Sizes from Twin to Cal King
- 100-night sleep trial
- 10-year warranty
- Good for stomach and back sleepers
Overall, the Leesa Original is a great foam mattress that offers impressive levels of comfort and support, with a few minor drawbacks in terms of its suitability for side sleepers. It’s also cheaper than the Casper Original.
Our fan-favorite, Original mattress features an all-foam makeup, with a breathable cover and exclusive top layer for cooler sleep and memory foam and a core support layer for comfort and support all night long.
Casper Original
If you’re looking for an affordable, entry-level mattress from Casper, stick with the Casper Original. This was the first model Casper produced and still stands out as one of the best around.
The Casper Original features a 3-layer construction. You’ll find a top layer of breathable polyurethane foam, a central layer of zoned memory foam that offers support in key areas like the hips and shoulders, and one final layer of base support foam.
When it comes to comfort and feel, the Casper Original offers reasonable bounce, great cooling and breathability throughout, and nice pressure-relieving comfort around the shoulders and hips, in particular. It has an even, balanced feel to it, with solidity right to the edges.
On the firmness scale, the Casper Original comes in at around a 7, offering more support than the Leesa Original and being a good choice for back, side, and even stomach sleepers, as well as those who move around between different positions in the night. It’s pretty impressive in terms of motion isolation too, being better for couples than the Leesa.
Casper Original Features
- Firmness rating of 7
- Sizes from Twin to Cal King
- 10-year warranty
- 100-night sleep trial
- Great for all kinds of sleepers
Overall, the Casper Original probably has more universal appeal than the Leesa Original. It can work well for side, back, stomach, and combo sleepers, and the zonal support makes it a good choice for those with back pain or discomfort too. However, you will have to pay a premium, as this mattress is more expensive overall.
The Casper Original Foam mattress is the perfect combination of support and cooling. Our ZonedSupportTM has three areas of targeted support for proper spinal alignment. Soft foam around the shoulders provide more relief to the upper body.
Who Should Get This?
Leesa
Leesa mattresses are more affordable than Casper mattress on the whole, making them a better option for people who want to save a little bit of cash and don’t mind making one or two minor compromises here and there.
In terms of pure comfort and support, these mattresses are terrific. The Leesa Original has one or two issues, but the Leesa Hybrid and Leesa Legend are some of the best mattresses on the market, excelling in all the right areas.
Casper
Casper mattresses may be more expensive, but they usually have the edge over Leesa counterparts in a few key areas like zonal support and breathability.
They’re a solid choice for people who tend to get hot in the night, as well as those who have back issues or aches in the hips and shoulders.
Models like the Wave Hybrid and Nova Hybrid are some of the best on the market, great for solo sleepers of all types, and good enough for couples too, although Leesa’s responsiveness and bounce may be more preferable in the eyes of some couples.
Our Pick
Both Leesa and Casper make some of the best mattresses in the business, offering amazing comfort, super support, and excellent blends of foams and springs throughout.
Our Pick: Casper
Overall, Casper just about gets the nod from us for its superiority in key areas like temperature control and support.
Leave a Reply